“My Boyfriend is Too Nice” & What to Do

My Boyfriend is Too Nice blog cover

You know what they say: nice guys finish last. But is this really true? And what if you’re dating one of those nice guys? How do you know when your boyfriend is “too nice”? Does being “too nice” actually exist? You might be surprised to hear that “my boyfriend is too nice” is a phrase that we hear a lot, and yes, it is a real thing.

On one hand, it’s great to have someone who is so kind and thoughtful. On the other hand, it can sometimes feel like he gives too much of himself and that this is coming from a place of insecurity.

So, let’s explore the idea of a “too nice” boyfriend.

“Nice” vs “too nice”

When it comes to dating, being “nice” is a turn-on, but being “too nice” is a turn-off. There’s a subtle but important distinction here.

Being nice comes from a place of confidence. It’s s about showing respect and kindness towards each other and making sure your partner’s needs are met. Being too nice comes from a place of lack. It’s about sacrificing your own needs in order to please someone else, so they keep you in their life.

So first, let’s talk about being nice. It’s comforting to have someone in your life who will go above and beyond for you. Having a boyfriend who is understanding and forgiving can bring a sense of safety to the relationship.

Nice boyfriends are there to listen, empathize, and offer advice without being judgmental or critical. He will have your best interests at heart and will be supportive of you and your goals. He won’t hesitate to give compliments and put in the effort.

These are all attractive qualities in a boyfriend when they come from a place of security and positive intentions.

Second, having a boyfriend who is too nice indicates that he is sacrificing his own needs for you, which can come across as weak or desperate. Setting boundaries and having standards are sexy because they show confidence and that someone isn’t going to settle. 

When a boyfriend is too nice, it can also indicate that he doesn’t have a fun, interesting life. If he gave up everything for you, it likely means that he didn’t have a full, fulfilling life in the first place.

Ultimately, being too nice when it comes to dating can make people lose respect for you, and you can’t have attraction without respect. While being nice is certainly a valuable trait, if you’re too nice when dating, you might just end up driving people away.

Being too nice comes from a place of lack and insecurity. If he is willing to do anything to keep you by his side, it indicates that he doesn’t value himself enough and doesn’t feel like what he has to offer is enough.

The challenges of having a boyfriend who is too nice

It can feel like a blessing and a curse when your significant other is too nice—they always make sure you have everything you need, they never forget an anniversary or birthday, and they are always willing to help out in any way possible. Sounds great, right? Not so fast.

1. It makes it difficult to have constructive conversations.

Resolving conflicts and having constructive conversations can be difficult when your partner is too nice. He might be hesitant to express his opinion for fear of hurting yours. This can lead to misunderstandings and communication issues. If one person isn’t honest and doesn’t stand up for what they believe in, it’s impossible to have a healthy relationship.

2. You may not reach your potential.

It’s important to be called out or challenged on things. Having a partner who is too nice means that this tends to happen very infrequently, if at all. If your boyfriend is too nice, he might not give you honest feedback that could help you grow as a person. A significant other is an important person in your life, and they are a key asset in helping you become the best version of yourself.

3. Your relationship can lack passion.

When your partner is too nice, it can make the relationship feel boring and passionless. It’s understandable to be nice, but if you’re too nice, it can lead to a lack of excitement in the relationship. This is because if your partner isn’t challenging you or pushing the boundaries, the spark can fade. For the reasons we discussed above, it’s difficult to feel chemistry with a boyfriend who is too nice.

4. The relationship can feel unbalanced.

Having a boyfriend who is too nice can leave you feeling like the relationship is unbalanced. If your partner is always giving and never receiving, it can lead to a feeling of imbalance and can make you feel like you have all the power. It might make you question why he feels the need to be so nice to you, and you can end up wondering what he is lacking to make him act in this way.

5. You can feel smothered.

When your partner is too nice, it can lead to a feeling of being smothered. If you’re in a relationship with someone who is always asking what they can do for you and always willing to help, it can make you feel overwhelmed. It’s important to maintain a sense of autonomy in a relationship and to have your own space. If your partner is too nice, it can make you feel like your freedom and independence are being taken away.

6. Your boyfriend may secretly become resentful.

While you may feel frustrated that your boyfriend won’t stand up for himself, he might be harboring feelings of resentment. If your boyfriend is too nice and gives in to all your demands, it can lead to him feeling like he is being taken for granted. Over time, this can lead to bitterness, even if you didn’t want him to be so giving.

7. Your boyfriend might feel like you owe him.

If your partner is always sacrificing their own needs for you, they may start to feel like they deserve something in return. This can be a tricky dynamic because it puts you in an uncomfortable situation—particularly if you didn’t ask for anything in the first place. This doesn’t occur in all situations where a boyfriend is too nice, but it’s a major red flag when it does happen. It’s manipulative and is essentially a way for him to gain control.

8. You can struggle to feel understood.

Ironically, having a boyfriend who is too nice can result in you feeling misunderstood. If your partner just goes along with everything you say and never challenges you, it can make it hard for him to truly understand your feelings and perspectives. You might even wonder if he is truly listening to what you are saying because he just agrees with everything.

9. You can end up feeling guilty.

When your boyfriend is too nice, it can make you feel like you don’t deserve all the effort he puts into the relationship. This can lead to feelings of guilt because most people innately know that a relationship should be balanced. Guilt can prevent you from truly enjoying your relationship and can cause a lot of unnecessary stress.

In order to have a healthy relationship, it’s important to communicate openly and strive for balance. Having a boyfriend who is too nice can make it difficult to find a healthy equilibrium.

What to do when “my boyfriend is too nice”

Having a boyfriend who is too nice isn’t automatically a dealbreaker. As is the case with a lot of issues in relationships, it can be possible to work through it with open and honest communication.

Here are five tips on dealing with a situation when your boyfriend is too nice. It’s a good idea to have a serious conversation about it and address the points below all at once. You’ll then need to keep a regular dialogue open to discuss whether things are going in the right direction.

1. Encourage him to speak up.

While it’s important to be mindful and kind, it’s also important for your boyfriend to be able to express his own thoughts and feelings. If he tends to get lost in your desires, encourage him to share his opinions. Remind him that it’s okay to have different opinions or ideas and that you are open to discussing them.

2. Set boundaries.

It’s important to set boundaries in any relationship, especially when one partner is too nice. Explain to your boyfriend that while you like that he is giving, it’s also important that you have time and space to yourself. Talk about what boundaries make sense for both of you, such as not talking all night or having separate hobbies.

3. Inspire him to work on himself.

If your boyfriend is too nice, it probably means that he’s got some self-work to do. Talk to him about what might be causing him to act this way and suggest that he works through those issues. This could be anything from low self-esteem to fear of rejection. It’s important for him to figure out the root cause of his behavior and work toward a healthier relationship dynamic.

4. Thank him for his kindness.

Just because your boyfriend is too nice, it doesn’t mean you should never thank him for his actions. In fact, it’s important to show appreciation for the things he does. It can also let him know that you appreciate certain behaviors. At the same time, it can be helpful for you to voice when you think his actions are coming from an unhealthy place.

5. Explain how his actions make you feel.

If you’re reading this post, then your boyfriend’s behavior is clearly having a negative impact on you in some way. Explain to him how his actions make you feel so he understands the situation and your thought process. If you feel a lack of chemistry, you should let him know that’s the issue. Perhaps you feel smothered? If so, tell him. It’s important to be open and honest and for your words to come from a place of love and understanding.

Whether you can work through this issue depends on your willingness to communicate openly and honestly and your boyfriend’s ability to recognize his behavior and take steps to change it.

Final thoughts on “my boyfriend is too nice”

Having a boyfriend who is too nice can be challenging for any relationship. But it’s important to remember that your relationship doesn’t necessarily have to end because your boyfriend is too nice.

With a little patience and understanding, it can be possible to resolve the issue and create a healthy relationship dynamic. At the same time, sometimes it’s necessary to end the relationship if it’s not serving either of you.

If you’re open and honest, no matter the outcome, you can take comfort in the fact that you gave it your best.

If you found this blog post helpful, you might also like Should Women Only Date Men Who Have Been to Therapy?

“Matching people using personality types is such a simple and powerful concept. So Syncd helped us find love, even in this difficult time. You’ve really changed our lives. In fact, we’re now married! Thank you.”

– Ben (INFJ) about Indy (ENFJ)

Get So Syncd the personality type dating app